Tuesday, August 9, 2011

WHY?


Cause and effect

RIC Z. BASTASA

Some are not really causes
But just symptoms
And we misdiagnose
A sickness
For a symptom
Of the real sickness

The cause
And the effect
Are often interchanged

For instance
Is poverty the cause
Of crime
Or is poverty
Only the symptom
Of it?

For instance
Is ignorance
The cause of poverty
Or is it simply
An effect of poverty?

Or is poverty
Nothing but an effect
Of ignorance?

Or is poverty
Just an effect
Of an oppression
Of the rich
Taking much
From the poor
Who gets poorer
Everyday
Because there
Are no reforms
Coming
To solve
His poverty
His ignorance
His having to commit a crime
To survive
His poverty
His ignorance
His being a crime
Of
Society itself
who never cared
And wanted him
Who never
Instituted the much
Promised reforms?

And so you doubt
The cause and effect
The effect from cause
And if you did not mind so
Well
They may always be
Interchanged
And mistaken
For the symptoms
The conditions
That always
Are
there deceiving.


4 comments:

  1. I think the poem's author is philosophizing and using too broad of a stroke to paint the cause and effect as one and the same. While many things in life could be linked at some elemental level ( "the big bang", evolution, shared environment), i do not believe that symptoms and causes are ever the same. Each personal story and instance is unique. That's why history never repeats itself. While a poor man may seem ignorant to his neighbor, his wife may think a world of him. Of course not all poor people are criminals who harbor jealousy and contempt for others. I am sorry , but I don't like generalizations and that's
    exactly what the author is doing in his poem.

    ReplyDelete
  2. For Sandra

    A week spent searching for why.
    Is it something lost, or something that never was.
    And, even more, did I set my hand, maybe now, maybe then, to feed the pulse that keeps this world on its crippled course?
    At search's end an answer found--not in the spinning,
    but rather the turning.
    Turning myself inward--to see you.
    I put out my hand and for this brief moment brake the spin.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Because of the recent riots in UK cities we find ourselves reflecting on the contents of these two pieces. We have come to this place and time because of the complex decisions made in all areas and levels of society and their consequences over the last decades .

    Let's do our little bit by trying to live out care and understanding of each other in quiet realistic actions of attentiveness? May they be heard above the din of blame ,fear and violence .Hoping thus to heal the wounds of our selfishness. It'll not be easy but is so much more worth while than the path of materialism ,image and celebrity at thees crosswords

    ReplyDelete
  4. I was directed to this today. I am thankful for more tools--another lesson for me to learn and exercise. I will continue to do what I can within my reach:


    http://tinybuddha.com/blog/how-to-help-someone-

    ReplyDelete